James was watching an episode of SEO Fight Club where different and unusual types of negative seo attacks could happen. He thinks it was Ted that talked about the potential for someone to add a 404 error message into a page and for the Google crawler to deindex that page. He decided to test the idea of adding a 404 error message to the comments section of a page and if it would drop rank.
Test Downloads
Transcription below:
Clint: Can rank be damaged by someone simply adding a 404 error into the comments on a page? This actually came from an SEO Fight Club episode. That episode derived from a, I want to say it was a comment or a blog post.
There's a blog post on Barry's Schultz Search Engine Land. Is that Barry Schultz I believe his name is? He wrote an article and someone, a Googler commented that you shouldn't have or that the phrase page 404 not found may be hurting people.
Dori: Was the phrase being on the page?
Clint: Yeah, cuz like, the implication..
Dori: Maybe he was talking about a 404 error message.
Clint: Yeah, which is a phrase you know, page not found, page 404 those messages. He's there implying that Googlebot is not smart enough to or instantly associated..
Dori: Put it in somebody's comments? It could be like a negative SEO thing?
Clint: Yeah, the Googlebot would actually not understand that it was a real page. Well, it would it would read all the pages, say page 404 not found and then stop crawling. It was another theory. So we talked about that. And Ted actually tested it on Barry's page. And the comments were all indexed until 10, updated his comment. And then the comment actually got removed from the index, because he had page 404 error not found it.
So James took this to a whole 'nother level and actually added it to a page and to see what could happen. And I mentioned 404 there, there's comment 404, you can probably test some variations page 404 not found, those kinds of things, messages that are typically associated with that 404 page, there's one error for his other one. Draft position eight stayed there. The index, but not the 404 error page, they came back, still the index. One more page is back now, stayed to number 5, back to number 3, number 4.
Dori: There's one in there that he re submitted them to omega, I think I saw that somewhere out there. Okay, wait, page got the index, but not the 404 error page.
Clint: I think he's saying that some of his test pages got the index. Which makes sense, because we'll talk about that in future tests here. But not the 404 page.
So that 404 page is still there, it stayed in the index, stayed in the index, stayed in the index and then disappeared. And then stayed gone from the 15th to the 24th meeting is not going to come back. So this leads us to a couple questions. One, can you really do that? And based off the testing that Ted did, he was able to get his comments not the index, but not the page. So intense test that was a failure.
In James's test, I would actually call this kind of inconclusive, just because you're gonna see why. But it has to do with the indexing of the rest of the test pages and what Google has decided. Hey, I wanted to keep versus what I didn't. And this could be a filtering thing. But it could also be because all these were good. And this one had a 404 error. And that's why I got rid of that one.
But I suspect that it's not so much because it kept it around through all these other D indexing phases. It just might have been, these are the two we really want. And you guys can even see my pointer so you can see my pointer, right?
Dori: Yeah
Clint: Okay, so these are the two we really wanted. And then we're going to test this one because it's a little bit different.
And then they did it again, these three we're going to test say this one and this one because they're little bit different and then finally these three we're gonna keep for the keyword because no one's clicking on this one, it's not different, but these seem to be better based off of whatever rabbit we pull that ever had at the time.
So, knowing that these pages are all equal keyword density is probably not keyword density. But that would be interesting to know kind of how they selected that random. This test also shoots one of my theories and we'll get into that when we were doing this Google filters by indexing and density. Oh by the way, what does this all mean to you?
One, you don't have to worry about people spamming your page or your comments and adding page 404 not found, though you probably should delete those anyway because they're just going to be junk for backlinks. So just know that this isn't a fear you guys have to worry about. You're going to be okay. No one's going to be running around with Scrapebox bustin those out and is Google's not going to remove your page.
If anything they get their own comments deindexed which is totally fine is not hurting you in any of these, but as always maintain and monitor your keywords or your comments.
