Test 518: Is There A Domain Age Bias In The SERPs?

It would seem obvious that the older a domain is, the more time it has to accrue links and rankings. But is that the case? We test that out to see what the truth is.

Test Downloads

Transcription below:

Clint: So what Joe did is he was looking at obviously the domain age and If you buy an older domain, will that domain result in a higher rankings for me based off of his age only? His process was a little bit different. I think SIA done this test before. I didn't have time to go back and look at the other test results to see but I'm pretty sure when Kyle was around.

Dori: Yeah, I did. So I can speak to that after this, after you got through it.

Clint: All right, good. So the way Joe's testing is a whole lot different from what the rest of us do, because he's got some tools like, literally some super nerd stuff that he does. And he does a whole lot of BI, visualizations and data collection and analysis, etc, they probably go above and beyond what I think anyone that I know of that is doing testing does.

It's great to have Joe here and his perspective. And in this case, he's actually used data collection and grabbed the 390 keywords that he found, you can see the search volume in there, it ranged from zero to 9000 the search volume, but most of them, the search volume didn't get any higher than 4400 searches per month, based off of the tool that he uses.

I'm not sure which one and he used in that regard. And then from each one of those keywords, you pull the top 100 results from all of those. So you do 390 times 100, what is that? 3900 different URLs or something like that? I'm crappy at math. So if I'm wrong, let's blamed on Dori. And then he also did a poll the top 50 results from 780 results and then grab the who is in those domains.

So, you think about that, in the numbers perspective, it's a lot of data and a lot of information to plug away and look at a couple of things that he found is that Wikipedia, you know, the big sites that we can all expect that are really dominated his keyword selection.

As a part of that, might be getting a little bit of ahead of myself, but I thought of it when I first saw this too is it's the keyword choices and the way Google is showing and being because he looked at being to the way Google is showing what we would deem as authority sites, the 800 pound gorilla sites that kind of took over in the particular set of keywords that he was looking at.

I don't know if that really impacted the results much in way of determining age, right? We know that Wikipedia, Investopedia, Yell. Yell has been around for a while not really bit high ranking, has been around for a while that might even be a typo for Yelp. And then obviously, YouTube, Amazon and TripAdvisor has kind of been around a while.

Then you see these mixes in here. And he shows us in the tables. And you can kind of read the tables a little bit more when you actually get a hold of the PDF, but looking at the occurrence and the rank count.

Dori: And actually, hold on the PDF is in the attachments. So they can download that right now and go through it, if you along with us and the handout.

Clint: Yeah, I was  slacking in today. And I forgot to do it again. Good looking at Dori.  And then the top 20 set and the occurrence with the counter the top 10. So, you know, you can pretty much see that. And I'm pretty sure this is supposed to be Yelp, Wikipedia, Yelp, Gumtree, Amazon, Marketing 91, Investopedia. I think these five or these three are all databases of information, right? And directories? Obviously, Amazon is what that is. And then these are information sites.

It must be Yell because of yeah, there you go. So it is Yell. And it looks like he's doing UK stuff. But you look at the data and based off of what they have. And it would indicate based off of the amounts of sites that are in there, that age is a factor, right? Because if you look at it all those sites are a lot older, they've already have established authority, etc.

They're dominating the search based off keyword pools that you have. And because of the keyword pools in the way that they are, is informational, etc. That's why the Wikipedia is heavy because Google for information on terms it really does favor Wikipedia a lot. And it kind of leads that along the lines of his results on what he's seeing, here's fancy graphs and stuff. And he has been, they think the best thing to do with just testing is gonna jump to the summary, unless you can read the, you know, the x and y axis and figure all this stuff out.

But it seems that according to what he saw, and just looking at his data is that older domains do take over the search results. However, when you look at it, is over older domains that Google is showing a lot of preference for Wikipedia, YouTube itself, Yelp directories, etc, those sites are naturally older anyway. And thus, it kind of makes you think or believe that you're looking at it's the age thing versus the perceived authority of the website that Google is giving it.

So the test, at the end of the day is kind of showing that it does show a bias if your domain is older, your domain is older, it's got a long better history. And it's been determined trustworthy in the results. By default, you're going to get increased rankings. But there's some things that he obviously broke down in the issues here. And those are his own. And what I would also recommend is probably find some search results that don't have so much that Wikipedia, YouTube, etc, representation into it.

See if you can look at it in a clear, less muddled way, where there's more information sites like, you know, like Dori's on website, or Keith Evans own website, or my website for example, not messing up the woodpile, as it were. So still a good.

Dori: Yeah, I like it. And, you know, when I did this test, what I found and I think I've spoke about this on previous webinars, is that the age counts when you have had content on it. Not that if you bought a domain or buy a domain that's 20 years old, and never had content, Google doesn't recognize that as an authority. So age in itself didn't play important. Unless it had content on it from the day you bought it.

So, if you are buying sites now, you know, put a WordPress site, put something on it. And that's going to rank up your authority in the long run when Google looks at age, you know, if they do. I don't know, I think it's a minor type of ranking factor. But it is still something to look at. And yeah, I agree. I think these dataset was heavily on the 800 pound gorillas that have no mass of sites. That's everybody, you know, linking to them, their interlinking is great.

Clint: Yeah. So what do we do with this? What is the business owner as the SEO agency do with this kind of this information? One, like Dori recommended, Ted Cobias is kind of said as to and I believe Lee Witcher over IMG said the same, if you're going to buy a domain for age make sure that, that is actually had indexed pages on it. Preferably are still in the index. So the ages relative kind of comparable to the amount of time that pages have been sitting in the index.

So like, if let's say you're doing a PBN thing and you're following Dori's stuff on PBNs and you want to build PBN stuff out. And but you don't have the time after you purchase your domains to set them up right, the way Dori is teaching you, then you need to at least get something on there and get a page in the domain set up in the index, Google finds it.

Even if it's a welcome, like, what is that coming soon. And then some cool guy graphics or something like that single page stuff doesn't even need to be special. But as long as that domain is in the indexed, when you get back to it, you know 3, 6 months or in my case like 4 years later then you'll actually get a value there. Yeah, I'm not lying, Bill Goldberg, he said this really great growth, quote, his potential is just means you haven't done anything yet. And I cleaned it up because if you need to go, then but yeah, my domain account is full of potential.

Dori: Mine too. In fact, I spent $3,000 on a mega site in a niche that I haven't done anything with yet. It was gonna, you know, I want it to be an affiliate site. I just haven't had the time but I was so excited when I found it and bid you know, outbid everybody and paid $3,005 for the dang thing.

Clint: Yeah, I got 4 affiliate sites that I know I could build like today and make money with those sitting in there, slacker!