Test 273: Will a Link from a Sub-Domain of the Same Website Have Any Effect?

One SIA user was having good results from placing links from a sub-domain (of the target domain). We test this out.

Test Downloads

Transcription Below

This test is by David Neale. We are trying to play with subdomains, we are trying to get links to and from to see if we can just, why take the time to build out a whole other website when you can build subdomains, is kind of the idea.

This was a fun test and David is a very new tester in the group and this was his first go and it had some errors in it and that is also why I wanted to show this because a lot of people are replicating these tests. So, there is so much that is learned when a test goes wrong. Just in what else can be done, different things that we could try, then also some kind of set up stuff.

He’s got this test set up where the idea is he is going to have a subdomain and link from it, is the concept, into the site itself. On this first set up, the target page that he was sending the link to ended up dropping to the bottom.

But what was very interesting about this test was that the subdomain refuses to index. So there is something else going in there that had nothing to do with the link itself. There are other things at play and I also realized how this whole environment is (not going to work), and that is ok. That happens and what is great was, David was able to identify the problem. One of the problems was that the subdomain never indexed.

At first, we thought the subdomain had a negative penalty, but it never indexed, that is not what was going on. It was a redo on it. He redoes it, the subdomain indexes and you can actually see it here. The page that was getting the links didn’t move but the subdomain moved to number one for the target keyword.

So then, this is a lesson, also probably in test set up issues, in that the subdomain contains the target keyword, it is entirely possible that the url is a stronger signal than any link that this page is going to send, as a result, it masks any value that this page could have received from that link. So this subdomain with the keyword is stronger than the link on the page, which was what I think was happening here.

Again, I wanted this test to kind of illustrate these things happen and there are still a lot to be learned. I think something that we learned from this is that we look at our sets of onpage factors, the keyword in the url is very strong but here is a pretty interesting thing, the keyword as part of your subdomain might be very strong.

So when you are looking at setting up subdomains, that is what you need to do, target categories, target keywords, things that you are searching, that is the route that you need to go for your particular site, getting that keyword in the subdomain would be a really strong thing and it might even be a stronger signal than any link coming out of the subdomain.