We know that meta titles are a critical SEO element.
Another MOZ Whiteboard Friday assertion is that a meta title optimized for a click will beat a meta title that is optimized for a keyword.
Since we have long put our keywords in our Title, we needed to see if MOZ was correct or not so we put it to the test and the answer will amaze you.
Test Downloads
Transcription Below
This particular Whiteboard was from April 2016.
In this discussion, Rand Fishkin says that there is no value in optimizing metatitles for keywords and then he backtracks to it and says any value is subsumed by wanting to draw clicks.
The idea is, it is more important to optimize for clicks.
The reason why it is such as huge statement is because we know that the number one signal for on-page optimization is the metatitle.
What he is saying is, forego the most important place to put a keyword that Google is looking at and do it this way.
We changed the target words so that then it would be a fake keyword but essentially left the structure exactly the same.
The optimized set up for the keyword exactly as he had and then we had the one for the clicks, just so we can look at the ranking factors, because maybe there is something in what he was talking about that it is not that strong of a ranking factor.
What we found in this test is a no. It is still a very strong ranking factor and you really need to get your keyword in the metatitle for ranking purposes.
But the concern that I have is that, if you are not ranking well, you will never get the click anyway.
To me, it is almost counterintuitive to say, “Don’t worry.
The clicks will come”. But if you are nowhere near ranking against something that is ranking, it is a hard one for me to grapple with.
That you would risk such an important place in the hopes that you might rank in another way and then get clickthrough rate.
My personal opinion, even before we look at clickthrough rates or the potential gains in the clickthrough rates, is to optimize for the keyword and then you can rank.
