Test 355: Does A Niche-Relevant PBN With a Lower SEO Metric Work Better Than a Generic PBN with High SEO Metrics?

Generally, this question of whether a niche relevant PBN with lower SEO metrics work better than a generic one with high SEO metrics shows up ALL the time and is something that came up again in the SIA membership group.

It prompted Dori to do a deeper dive into Topical Association of SEO Metrics.

On a link builder’s level, the answer to this is really important as it can change the way one builds links, the cost of them, and where one goes to get them.

Test Downloads

Transcription Below

We're starting with test 355. That is Topical Test 2 in this series of deep diving into topical and this one is about relevant sites, actually PBNs.

I get questions all the time, people asking me: does a niche relevant PBN with a lower SEO metric work better than a generic PBN with higher SEO metrics and I would always typically think, yes. I always thought they did and that was based on my experience, not any testing that we've ever done and best practices, I would always say, well, best practice is get something from a niche relevant site if you can.

So, we decided to test it.

Now, I’m going to scroll down a little bit. We have sites that got the link and then two PBNs that sent the links.

Now, because this was topical related we had to actually put the test pages on the first site, which was a PBN. That has test pages that do have lorem ipsum on it and I’m going to talk about that in a second.

The site that is sending the links is in the identical topical niche, the site that is receiving the links and that's arts / music and this is topical TrustFlow in Majestic.

The one giving the link is in a category that has nothing to do with arts and music and that's shopping and clothing. Although maybe somebody out there can disagree about that but in any case with numbers and binary code it does not have anything to do with arts and music. It has nothing to do with it.

The site in the niche giving the links has a TrustFlow of 9. The site that doesn't have any relation to that same topical has a TrustFlow of 31. We'll get to see the effect of that.

Now, note that the test pages have lorem ipsum. The site the pages that are sending the links also have lorem ipsum. Because of that this is really testing the domain topical or relevance.

So, it's not the content are surrounding the link. That would be the next test that we're going to do. In any case, we have the site, we have arts of music, TrustFlow 5 is the site that's got to get the links. Sending the links is a TrustFlow of 9 from arts and music and then the shopping and clothing site TrustFlow of 31. So, what do you think?

Here's our setup. These are the pages in the site that's receiving the link and this is what we did.

We put the high TrustFlow going to this site and then the niche PBN over to here and just because I thought that the high TrustFlow is going to win I wanted it to have to climb a higher ladder rank. That's why I put it below the niche relevant one and so the results are below.

Let's scroll down and baboom! The high TrustFlow did indeed win. So, this was the coming out right after we indexed them. It settled down. This was the next day the page with the same niche, it rose up. I think it rose up. Let's see what did it rise up. It was one, two, three, four from the bottom. Same thing. One, two, three actually it went down and it had gone down here to so maybe that's something else. That's really interesting. Why is something with a link would go down? But even today when I checked it it's in the same arena here and this one is still very much on top and this is in this area and that's where it has stayed since. So, the page with the non-relevant domain one hands down.

I just love it when stuff like that happens because everybody has always said best practices get a topical link from a site that is in your same topic but clearly the myth is busted when you're just looking at domains. It doesn't matter. Get as high the metrics as you can and don't even look at the relevance when you can if you're buying links or doing links and there's not any content around them.

The next test is going to be the same type of test but it's going to have relevant content around it and we're going to see if the high SEO metrics site wins still or not. It may not. Well, we're going to see. I look forward to next month and doing that but right now this is pretty much following the line that I thought it would because like I said I think the topical stuff when it comes to linking is just a bunch of BS.