Test 134: Is Dwell Time a Ranking Factor?

One of the SIA members asked whether we had tested dwell time. We hadn’t, so we thought we’d give it a go. 

Test Downloads

Transcription Below

Dwell time is an interesting concept. It is basically time on site but Google Analytics and other tools that measure user engagement cannot give you time on site unless you get another click. For example, if somebody comes to your page and they stay for 25 minutes, they do not click on anything and then they leave, that is a bounce and then their time on site is not recorded.

In order to get actual time on site, they need one more click. Google needs that extra click to another page in order to gauge the time on site. Dwell time would be that 25 minutes, click or no click. The idea here is that, can Google measure that, theoretically, yes - but is it a ranking factor? That is what we are going after with this test.

Can we send users to a page? have them site there for a decent amount of time to show that this is a good content versus other test pages that aren’t getting that dwell time even though we are not talking about a click – so bounce rate is not really what we are talking about here, we are just looking at coming to a page and sitting on it. And if you do a decent research on this, you will see that a lot of people thing that yes, this is a ranking factor.

This test was put together by Ryan Hough who did a really good job at this. Dwell time is a really weird concept. There is a good content here and we took some concepts here – feel free to go over the research if dwell time is a little bit fuzzy in my explanation there.

What we wanted to do was to send visitors just to a page, not clicking on it, in a sense, it is a bounce but they stayed on the page a fair amount of time. Some people are pointing in that dwell time is an actual thing is a feature that used to exist – it does not exist anymore but Google used to say – would you like to block these results from the serps or would you like more of this results? learn more about this.

Where people thought where that determination or feature was coming from was from dwell time – if you went to a page and bounced immediately and your dwell time was low, Google was asking would you like to take this out from your personal results vs when you are spending a lot of time even if you were not clicking but your dwell time was high.

Google would offer you more options to see more from that site. That is where speculation came from, that dwell time was being taken into consideration. These features do not exist anymore. It went away maybe 2015 or so.

In this test set up, Ryan was using BrowSEO. If you are not familiar with BrowSEO, it is a pretty tool where you can essentially create fake personas and have people that live within your BrowSEO browser and you can switch between them without closing your browse.

Within the platform itself, it will maintain the passwords, IPs, other user data that a real person would have, and you can bounce between different personas and they are seen as different people online. So, using BrowSEO with 3 different personas and we are sending them to the test page to sit on the page and leave so that the dwell time would go up.

The concept here is that, if dwell time was a factor, the test page would go up even though essentially they have the same bounce rate and not really recording time on site.

Interestingly, what ended up happening on this test which was totally unexpected. The test page hit the bottom and stayed at the bottom. Very surprising results. Do I think that dwell time is a negative ranking factor? I don’t but there are some concepts as to what might have gone wrong here. It is entirely possible, and this is the scary part, is that Google identified this as not real traffic.

Ryan was doing this on a Friday, they all came from the same Amazon IP, since he was the user even if there were three different BrowSEO personas, he was basically typing in the same way, the amount of time spent on all the pages were similar, and they weren’t logged in users. It is possible that Google has identified these as fake.

That, to me, is I think the most unlikely result, I think the last one would be possible – they are not logged in as users and it is conceivable in my mind that Google would track it if these people were logged in to Chrome. That is where the user engagements might come from, where it has the ability to actually track these things is through logged in users.

That is a little bit more difficult to emulate in a test environment but that to me tells me that in my mind, that is where the money is at – that Google wasn’t tracking these things, it didn’t see these as different dwell times because the users were not logged in. That is where I think where things went wrong. I have a hard time believing that dwell time is a negative factor and I also have a hard time believing that Google has identified them as fake users and punished the particular page.

I do not know why they would do that because all of the pages were being seen as fake views. Where I think maybe the issue lies is in they weren’t logged in which then did not give that page the benefit of the dwell time.

How many visit?

The visits weren’t that many. I think there were 5 to each page. Not a ton of visits but they were spaced out in a certain amount of time. I think 2-3 weeks. Actually, I might have done it over a month, now that I think about it. So it was not an incredible amount of visits and what actually might happened to that test page because it dropped was simply it could have been an algo shift.

Since all the pages were the same, Google just recalculates and reshuffles the test pages, kind of within the time that the test started and completed.